Got a pumpkin sitting on your porch? Don’t throw it away! Make it into delicious homemade pumpkin pie instead. This fresh homemade pumpkin pie made from a real pumpkin is easy to make and tastes fresher and brighter than canned.

Fresh pumpkin pie made with real pumpkin

 

As someone who hates wasting money, I can’t let any food go to waste.

Whether that’s bits of leftover food in my fridge or freezer… or that decorative pumpkin on my front porch – That’s food! 

So every year, after Halloween and before Thanksgiving, I turn my decorative pumpkins into pumpkin puree that can be used to make many different recipes, including fresh pumpkin pie.

Today I’m going to show you exactly how to turn a pumpkin into pumpkin pie.

 

Is pumpkin pie from a real pumpkin worth it?

Honestly, it depends on what you’re after. A pie pumpkin costs me about $4 and makes enough puree for 4 pies, so it’s usually cheaper than canned. The flavor is also a little brighter and the filling is silkier. The tradeoff is time: you have to roast the pumpkin and drain the puree so the pie doesn’t turn out watery.

Canned is the easy option, and there’s no shame in it. But if you want to try something different this Thanksgiving, I think it’s worth doing at least once!

How To Make Pumpkin Puree

For detailed instructions, check out this tutorial on making pumpkin puree from a pumpkin. But here’s the process, in a nutshell:

  • Cut pumpkin into smaller pieces: A large jack-o-lantern pumpkin can be cut into 4 pieces. Remove seeds and stringy insides.
  • Place on a large sheet pan and roast at 400F for about an hour.
  • Remove from oven, allow to cool, and remove skin.
  • Place pumpkin in a blender and blend until smooth.
  • Place pureed pumpkin in a strainer set over a bowl. Let it sit for an hour to remove excess water – there should be quite a bit!
  • Your pumpkin puree is ready to use in pumpkin pie, in another recipe, refrigerated for a few days or frozen for future use.

Can I use any pumpkin?

I have been making pumpkin puree from large carving pumpkins for years. They taste great when made into pies or pumpkin soup. You may have read online that you shouldn’t use the jack-o-lantern type of pumpkin, but you can.

Smaller “pie pumpkins” also work. They are typically a little less watery and more flavorful than the larger pumpkins. In either case, you’ll want to drain excess moisture from the roasted and pureed pumpkin to avoid watery pie. More on that, below.

Safety note: Make sure your pumpkin is uncarved, firm, and free of mold or soft spots.

Want to save this recipe?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Pie Ingredients

Once you have the pumpkin puree made, the rest of the pie ingredients are cheap and accessible – you might have all of these ingredients on hand in your pantry right now:

  • Evaporated milk
  • Eggs
  • Brown sugar
  • Pumpkin pie spice (or individual spices including cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice)
  • Salt
  • Pie crust: You can make your own following this recipe (ignore the peach pie and go straight for the crust recipe) or buy frozen pie crust at the grocery store (Marie Callender’s is my favorite frozen pie crust brand)

How To Avoid Watery Pie

One of the main complaints of people making fresh pumpkin pie with a real pumpkin is that the pie gets watery.

The fix? It is essential to drain the roasted and pureed pumpkin before mixing up the pie ingredients.

To do so, simply set the puree in a fine strainer positioned over a bowl. Let it sit for an hour (or overnight) and much of the excess water will drain into the bowl. The puree is more concentrated and better suited for using in recipes.

Homemade pumpkin pie with pumpkin puree

Homemade Pumpkin Pie With Real Pumpkin

Yield: 8 slices
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 1 hour
Additional Time: 1 minute
Total Time: 1 hour 16 minutes

You can make homemade pie crust or frozen for this recipe. I like Marie Callender's frozen pie crust.

No Ratings

Ingredients

  • 2 cups pumpkin puree
  • 12-ounce can evaporated milk
  • 2 large eggs, beaten
  • 3/4 cup brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1 deep dish frozen pie crust

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 400F. Gather all pie ingredients in a large mixing bowl and beat with an electric mixer until well combined.
  2. Pour pumpkin pie mixture into the crust. Leave 1/2" at the top as pie will expand slightly.
  3. Bake at 400F for 15 minutes. Turn down oven temperature to 350F and bake for an additional 40 to 45 minutes, until center of pie is set.
  4. Remove from oven and allow to cool completely before cutting.

Did you like this recipe?

Please give it a 5-star review on the recipe card above!