Pimento-Green Olive Cheese Spread

Pimento-green olive cheese spread recipe: A twist on the classic. Click through for recipe!

Pimento cheese is one Southern recipe that the rest of the country needs to adopt.


Because it’s a cheese and dip in one! It’s full of flavor, and can be enjoyed in SO many ways (see below for ideas).

If you haven’t tried pimento cheese before, now is your chance.

This recipe calls for green olives stuffed with pimentos (the cheap green olives found in every grocery store). If you want the traditional pimento cheese, use straight pimentos instead of green olives stuffed with pimentos.

Pimento and green olive cheese spread. Delicious with pita chips and veggies. Click through for recipe!

Pimento Cheese Serving Suggestions

How should this pimento-green olive cheese spread be eaten? Here are my favorite ways:

  • Served as a dip, along with homemade pita chips or homemade bagel chips, and fresh veggie slices
  • Spread on top of celery slices
  • Used as a sandwich spread (make the best BLT sandwich ever!)
  • Used as a base for homemade mac & cheese
  • Used as a burger topping
  • Used as a filling for jalapeno poppers (Slice jalapenos in half and remove seeds. Fill each half with pimento cheese. Broil for 2 to 3 minutes.)
  • Used on tuna melts (spread pimento cheese directly on bread, or place on top of tuna before baking)

Recipe Tip: Cheese

Use a block of cheese instead of buying a bag of shredded cheese. Here’s why:

  • The cheese should be finely shredded (using the fine blades on any cheese grater). Most packaged shredded cheese is more coarsely shredded.
  • Packaged shredded cheese usually has extra ingredients to prevent caking (like cellulose powder, potato starch, and calcium sulfate).  These extra ingredients are not needed for this recipe.

Also, use mild cheddar cheese for this recipe. I find sharp cheddar cheese flavor to be too strong for such a concentrated dip.

Pimento-Green Olive Cheese Spread

Yield: 4 cups cheese spread

Total Time:20 min

This makes a big batch (almost 4 cups). Feel free to half it for a smaller batch.


  • 1 lb block mild cheddar cheese
  • 1/3 cup mayonnaise
  • 1/2 cup softened cream cheese (or cottage cheese, in a pinch)
  • 1 teaspoon garlic powder
  • Hot sauce, to taste
  • 2/3 cup pimento-stuffed green olives, sliced


  1. Use a fine grater to grate the block of cheese.
  2. Mix cheese with mayonnaise, garlic powder, and hot sauce.
  3. Gently fold green olives into cheese mixture.
  4. The cheese spread is ready to eat now - and can be refrigerated for up to 4 days.
Homemade lefse, made in a frying pan. No special equipment needed! Click through for recipe.

Norwegian Lefse (Made In A Frying Pan)

Do you hear that? That’s the sound of a thousand Norwegian grandmothers gasping at the thought of making lefse any other way than the...

Exploring coffee alternatives: If you are trying to avoid caffeine but still love the taste of coffee, read on.

Exploring Coffee Alternatives

Trying to break your coffee habit or avoid caffeine? It’s not an easy thing to do. Decaf may be an option, but it’s not...

EPIC monster cookies. They are LOADED with M&Ms. Click through for recipe!

Epic Monster Cookies

Would you like some cookie with your M&M’s?  When it comes to monster cookies, I like mine loaded with M&M’s and chocolate chips. What’s...

Vegetable pizza, served cold: A great make-ahead appetizer. Click through for recipe!

Cold Vegetable Pizza

If you’ve never had cold veggie pizza, you’re in for a treat. It’s comprised of: A crescent roll crust A layer of herb cream...

Make-ahead egg cups: Breakfast made easy! Click through for recipe.

Make-Ahead Breakfast Egg Cups

When it comes to your average daily breakfast, which statement best describes you? 1: I have plenty of time to make a good breakfast...

Confetti chicken meatballs: Lots of veggies make these healthy and delicious. Paleo-friendly.

Paleo Confetti Chicken Meatballs

This is one of those use-up-odds-and-ends-in-your-fridge recipes. But all the flavors came together beautifully. These meatballs are moist, flavorful, and full of colorful veggies...