Americans spend an average of $3.9 billion each year on Halloween candy. This year, skip the store-bought and consider making your own Homemade Halloween candy from scratch. From candy bars to taffy to Starburst to bubble gum – this list has you covered.50 Homemade Halloween Candy Recipes - a recipe roundup from Cheap Recipe Blog

Updated 10/11/2025

Do you shamelessly dig into your child’s Halloween treat bag?

No judgment here.

But if you’re like me, all of that Halloween candy starts to blend together after awhile.

I love candy bars as much as the next person. But seriously – house after house, year after year, it’s the same darn candy.

This year for Halloween, why not try something new? Make homemade versions of your favorite Halloween treats. Plan some kitchen time before Halloween to make treats for your family, co-workers and neighbors. And maybe even the trick-or-treaters!

Without further ado, here are 50 homemade Halloween candy recipes to get you started:

Classic Halloween Candy Recipes

Recreate your favorite store-bought candy. Here are copycat recipes for store-bought candy favorites, like Snickers, Milky Way, Rolos, Twizzlers, and more.

Found a recipe you love? Share it with friends or pin it for later!

Homemade Halloween Candy Recipes: Make Something NEW

Venture out of your comfort zone and making something new and unique.

Popcorn balls: Learn how to make these simple treats at home with just 3 ingredients + optional add-ins.

Make Something Healthy(ish)

Delicious Halloween candy doesn’t have to send you into a sugar coma. Here are some treats on the healthier side – but still really fun to make and eat.

If you’re looking for something savory and Halloween-themed to serve at a party, check out these fun Halloween painted sandwiches which can be made into different shapes and colors.

But Wait… Are You Going To Save Money By Making Your Own Halloween Candy?

Probably not.

But when you start adding the cost of ingredients up, candy recipes are generally not too expensive. We’re dealing with sugar, butter, and flour here. Not fresh produce, meat, or specialty ingredients. This makes for cheaper (albeit not heathier) recipes.

Making your own Halloween candy is a fun and creative way to save money, especially when you buy ingredients in bulk. Here’s how to stretch your budget by purchasing key candy-making staples like sugar and chocolate at warehouse stores:

  • Shop at Warehouse Clubs: Stores like Costco, Sam’s Club, or BJ’s Wholesale offer bulk sizes of sugar, flour, chocolate chips, and nuts at lower per-unit prices than regular grocery stores. For example, a 25-pound bag of granulated sugar at Costco often costs less than $15, compared to $3-$4 for a 4-pound bag at a supermarket.
  • Choose Versatile Ingredients: Buy multi-use items like semi-sweet chocolate chips, which work for recipes like homemade Snickers, Reese’s eggs, or chocolate-covered honeycomb. A 72-ounce bag of chocolate chips at a warehouse store can cost around $10-$12, enough for multiple batches of candy.
  • Check for Deals: Look for seasonal discounts at warehouse stores around Halloween, as they often stock baking supplies in bulk. Use store apps or websites to find coupons or member-only deals for even more savings.
  • Store Properly to Avoid Waste: Store bulk sugar in airtight containers to keep it fresh for months. For chocolate, keep it in a cool, dry place or freeze it to extend shelf life, ensuring you can use leftovers for future recipes.
  • Split with Friends: If a 50-pound bag of flour or a giant tub of coconut oil feels like too much, split the cost and quantity with friends or family to make bulk buying manageable.
  • Compare Unit Prices: Before buying, check the per-ounce or per-pound price on bulk items to ensure you’re getting a true deal. Some warehouse stores list this on the price tag for easy comparison.

By buying in bulk, you can make dozens of homemade Halloween candies for a fraction of the cost of store-bought treats. Plus, you’ll have ingredients left over for holiday baking or future candy-making.

Looking for a non-food idea to help make your kid’s Halloween fun? Check out this cute Halloween coloring page or this collection of Halloween word searches.

And last but not least… don’t forget to like Cheap Recipe Blog on Facebook and follow my Pinterest boards. I do a lot of recipe roundups, and feature those recipes on my boards and Facebook page. Let’s stay in touch!