Gift-Worthy Recipes: Homemade Nut Butters

3 homemade nut butter recipes: Peanut, Pecan, and Cashew. Makes a great gift! Repin to save.

Looking for a homemade gift that is delicious, practical, and not loaded with sugar? Homemade nut butters are the answer!

Pretty much any nut can be made into a nut butter. I used peanuts, cashews, and pecans. But other options include hazelnuts, almonds, walnuts, macadamia nuts – and even seeds, like sunflower seeds, pepitas, and sesame seeds.

3 homemade nut butter recipes: Peanut, Pecan, and Cashew. Makes a great gift! Repin to save.

To Toast Or Not To Toast?

Toasting nuts before processing them in the food processor adds extra flavor to the final product. I would highly recommend this step (although it is not absolutely necessary.)

Customizing Your Nut Butter Flavors

To vary the flavor, you can add all sorts of other ingredients, like honey, maple syrup, sea salt, cinnamon, cocoa, vanilla extract, nutmeg, and powdered ginger. You can even add savory spices to nut butter.

Homemade nut butters: Cashew, Pecan, and Peanut butter. Repin to save!


Making Them Gift-Worthy

  • Package them in 4-ounce Mason jars
  • For a bigger gift, give a set of 3 nut butters, along with some jam and a decorative spreading knife
  • On a budget? Peanut butter is the cheapest option.

Make homemade nut butters for a gift! 3 recipes here. Repin to save.

Check out my other gift-worthy recipes, and don’t forget to stay in touch via Facebook and Pinterest to get the latest updates and posts!

Print Print

Homemade Nut Butters

Total Time: 25 min

To toast nuts: Preheat oven to 350F. Place nuts in a single layer on a baking sheet. Bake for 5 minutes. Remove from oven, stir nuts, and return to oven for 3 minutes. Check to see if the nuts are toasted. If not, stir, and return to oven for 2 more minutes. Keep an eye on the nuts, as they can quickly burn. Be sure to cool nuts completely before pureeing.


Peanut Butter:
2 cups toasted peanuts
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon honey

Cashew Butter:
2 cups toasted cashes
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon maple syrup

Pecan Butter:
2 cups toasted pecans
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 tablespoon maple syrup
1/2 teaspoon cinnamon


Place nuts in a food processor. Process for several minutes, scraping down sides in between. It may take 5 minutes or more to make a smooth nut butter. Once you're happy with the consistency, add the salt, sweetener, and other desired add-ins. Place nut butter in a glass jar, and keep refrigerated for up to 1 month.

3 Last minute gifts from the kitchen. Pin to your Food Gifts board!

3 Last-Minute Gifts From The Kitchen

The “Gifts From The Kitchen” obsession continues! This time, I’m sending you over to the Betty Crocker website – where I contribute recipes and articles from time to time – to get the...

The Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap, 2014

Chewy Chocolate Chip Gingersnaps With Spiked Eggnog Glaze

COOKIES! Once again, I participated in The Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap. Why? Because I love cookies and I love getting packages in the mail. And the best part is that this event...

Holiday gift guide from Cheap Recipe Blog

Thrift Store Christmas Shopping

#Thrift store #christmas #shopping – here I go! A photo posted by Haley (@cheaprecipeblog) on Dec 12, 2014 at 12:12pm PST How did I spend an oddly warm December Saturday in Minnesota? Thrift...

Lemon skin balm makes a great gift. 3 ingredients. Smells awesome. Repin to save.

Gift-Worthy: Lemon Skin Balm

Homemade gifts are generally inexpensive and always thoughtful. And homemade gifts do not have to be made out of sugar. Case in point, this skin balm that smells AMAZING. Like a lemon cookie,...

Cacao nib & honey caramels make a great gift! Repin to save.

Gift-Worthy Recipes: Cacao Nib Honey Caramels

Ever since I started my blog back in 2011, I have devoted most of my December posts to gift-worthy recipes. Everyone needs a repertoire of recipes that are so pretty – so delicious...

Use leftover turkey & cranberries to make these delicious wontons. Repin to save!

Thanksgiving Leftover Recipes: Turkey & Cranberry Wontons

Repurposing leftover Thanksgiving foods is not only practical, it’s also quite fun. Truth be told, I didn’t know if the flavors in this recipe would work well together. But they did. That sweet...